ChatGPT Review: Resume Writing Edition

Apr 18

How useful is ChatGPT in crafting a resume that lands interviews and job offers?

ChatGPT is OpenAI’s language model that’s designed to generate human-like responses to questions, engage in conversation, and even create a wide range of content from social media captions to essays. ChatGPT is artificial intelligence that uses data collected from books, websites, and other online content to generate responses—and it has caught the attention of job seekers.

Users of ChatGPT have shown that it can be used to create resumes, cover letters, practice interview questions, and job search strategies which can save you hours throughout your job search. The potential of ChatGPT is a godsend to job seekers who find themselves too exhausted after their 9-5 to research, write, edit, rewrite, proofread, tailor, and eventually submit a strong targeted resume to online job postings.

As a Certified Resume Writer, I first experimented with ChatGPT to identify its faults and join my colleagues in persuading job seekers not to use it to craft their resumes. I asked straightforward requests to “write a resume for a (JOB TITLE) job” and “tailor my resume for this job posting.” And with these types of requests or prompts, ChatGPT won’t help you make the moves you want to make in your career.

I was shocked to discover that, when you ask the right questions, ChatGPT can certainly help you craft a job-winning resume in a fraction of the time it would take you on your own and for an even smaller fraction of the time that you may wait on a first draft from a Certified Resume Writer or resume service.

This blog contains affiliate links, meaning I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you) if you subscribe or buy something through the links I share. I only share links to products or services that I use myself or absolutely love!

Top Mistakes Using ChatGPT To Write A Resume

Over the last 6 months, I’ve seen a handful of job search and career coaches on Instagram advertising that you can either ask ChatGPT to “write a resume for a (JOB TITLE) job” to get a rough outline of targeted details for your resume based on the typical tasks, desired skills and abilities, and qualifications of that role; or to “tailor this resume for this job posting” where they’d copy and paste the text of a specific job posting and their resume.

I tested both of these approaches multiple times.

When asking ChatGPT to “write a resume for a (JOB TITLE) job,” some iterations generated an extremely broad resume that resembled a job posting. The outline of an organized resume was there (although, the outdated objective and references available upon request elements were offputting), but the bullets looked copied and pasted from a generic job description.

In another iteration, ChatGPT stated:

“As an AI language model, I cannot write a resume for a (JOB TITLE) job based on the information you’ve provided. I cannot guarantee that the resume will be of high quality, as it requires a deep understanding of your professional background, experiences, and accomplishments. It is best to seek the help of a professional resume writer or customize a resume template to fit your unique skills and experience. Additionally, it is important to ensure that your resume aligns with the requirements and expectations of the specific HR manager job you are applying for.”

Of course, that response made me smile. (It’s learning!)

When I provided the text from my resume and an entry-level HR job posting, asking ChatGPT to tailor the resume for that job posting, the results were just as disappointing. Most of the details inserted into my resume were skills, abilities, and experience I didn’t have which was especially frustrating since I used an entry-level job posting.

Limitations of ChatGPT

ChatGPT is very transparent and upfront that it may generate incorrect information, may produce harmful instructions or biased content, and has limited knowledge of the world and events after 2021. I asked ChatGPT specifically what its limitations were regarding resume writing. It responded:

“As an AI language model, I can generate text and provide guidance on resume writing, but there are some limitations to my abilities:

I do not have personal knowledge of an individual's work history, accomplishments, or unique experiences, which may be essential for creating a compelling and effective resume.

I may not be able to provide industry-specific advice or jargon that is relevant to a particular job or field.

I cannot guarantee that a resume will lead to a job offer or interview, as many factors influence hiring decisions.

I may not be able to account for cultural or regional differences in resume styles or preferences.

I cannot provide legal or professional advice on the inclusion of certain information, such as age, gender, or marital status, which may be subject to legal restrictions or best practices.

I may not be able to account for recent changes in hiring practices or technology, which may require updated information or formatting on a resume.

Therefore, it is always recommended to use my guidance as a starting point and to seek feedback from professionals or individuals with expertise in resume writing or the relevant industry.”

How To Write A Resume With ChatGPT

The key to writing a resume with ChatGPT is to use it strictly for research, analysis, an outline, and a formula generator. You’ll need to be an editor to craft a job-winning, true-to-you resume with artificial intelligence.

You can start by using ChatGPT to research the top qualifications and desired skills and abilities for the role you’re pursuing. You can also use this tool to analyze job postings and isolate the top qualifications and skills. This will give you an outline of keywords to highlight and important experience to expand on throughout your work history.

You can also use ChatGPT to list the typical tasks for the role you’re targeting to use as an outline for what you should include in your Experience section. Since ChatGPT doesn’t have personal information regarding your work history and accomplishments, you will have to pick and choose which details are true-to-you to showcase in your resume.

What will separate you from other applicants with similar skills and experience will be the accomplishments that you draw attention to in your resume. You can use ChatGPT to craft formulas for achievement bullets with metrics based on the goals or top desired skills and abilities of the role you’re pursuing. I refer to them as formulas because the achievement bullets will have metrics and examples that may not be true to your experience but will serve as a foundation that you can revise to reflect your own accomplishments.

15-minute Resume With ChatGPT

ONLY $37

Quickly create a master resume from scratch using AI tools and an ATS-compliant, fill-in-the-blank style modern resume template designed by a Certified Resume Writer

Includes Mid to Late Career Edition resume template, video guide using ChatGPT, AI Chat Cheat Sheet, and Resume Targeting Checklist ($144 Value)

Why ChatGPT Recommends Working With A Resume Writer

ChatGPT confessed to not being able to provide industry-specific advice or jargon, account for cultural or regional differences in resume styles or preferences, and account for changes in hiring practices or technology. These are all areas that Certified Resume Writers specialize in. I also asked what a Certified Resume Writer could do better than ChatGPT, and the reply was:

“Personalization: A certified resume writer can provide personalized and customized resume writing services that take into account the client's unique skills, experience, and career goals. They can provide a level of personalization that an AI language model cannot match.

Human touch: A certified resume writer can provide a human touch to the resume writing process, taking into account the client's personality, tone, and voice.

Industry knowledge: A certified resume writer has specialized knowledge and expertise in writing resumes for specific industries and career levels. They can provide industry-specific advice on what recruiters are looking for and how to present your skills and experience.

Feedback and revisions: A certified resume writer can provide feedback and revisions based on your feedback and the job posting's requirements. They can work with you to make sure that your resume is polished and meets your expectations.

Consultation and advice: A certified resume writer can provide consultation and advice on career planning, job search strategies, and other aspects of the job search process.”

It’s no secret that AI tools are learning to replicate actual voices, and over time ChatGPT may learn to adapt a person’s written tone and voice. Until then, that’s an element of resume writing that still needs the human touch. Recruiters are already sharing how easy it is to tell if a resume was written by an AI tool like ChatGPT.

Conclusion

Since November, artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT have been making headlines and catching the attention of social media influencers. It’s been a hot topic with both praise (as a time-saving resource for example) and negative press (because it’s potentially going to take human jobs - or take over the world). As a Certified Resume Writer, I see both the shocking advantages of using ChatGPT to quickly write and tailor a resume as well as the easy-to-make mistakes and shortcuts that could cost you the job.

Steph Cartwright, CPRW // Certified Resume Writer

Author Profile: Steph Cartwright, CPRW

Steph Cartwright is a Certified Resume Writer, LinkedIn Strategist, and Founder of Off The Clock Resumes. She helps job seekers get unstuck and get a foot in the door at the companies they’d love to work for with their resumes, LinkedIn profiles, and job search plans.

What’s keeping you stuck in your job search? Take this quiz to find out…